Future Fit

The future of South Africa and Africa is ours to create!

A good reason to go

I wrote this article recently for the Mail & Guardian. I have since had some interesting responses to it, so I thought I’d put it up on my blog.

I have been asked to write a piece on why I believe that you as a student should stay in South Africa in the face of the issues that we have to deal with here, particularly the unacceptable levels of crime. But I’m not going to do that, because I don’t believe, and I have never believed, that students should stay in the country when they graduate. In fact I believe that the more graduates who leave South Africa, the better, as long as they come back enriched by their experiences abroad.

What I do recommend, however, is that you avoid telling everyone around you that you are going forever because this place has no future. You may feel like that now, especially if you’ve been a victim of crime, but you don’t honestly know how you will feel after a few years away. Leaving with a great fanfare of negativity makes it hard for you to come back with dignity when you’re done wandering the globe, and you can take it from me that you will eventually miss home. You can always make new friends but you can never make old friends.

We South Africans seem to think that we have some sort of monopoly on problems, particularly on crime. But just in the past week there have been several disturbing examples from abroad, including a bizarre yet intricate plot in the USA by a group of 9-year olds to murder their teacher, clean up the blood and hide the murder weapons. There was also the case of the great nephew of Cape Town’s Sir De Villiers Graaff, a student, who was shot dead in Mexico trying to defend his mother from two muggers.

By travelling you will see that the grass is not always greener on the other side. You will experience that when a power cut affects 15 million people in Florida, chaos ensues, as it has over the past few years in California, Brazil and Chile amongst others. In India or Egypt you’ll find that they just get on with things anyway, despite having no power, but there you will get sick, because that’s what happens when basic hygiene is so much worse than your body is used to. You will find that your luggage gets lost everywhere, like the 20,000 pieces that were lost last week at Heathrow. In Turkey you will learn that their constitutional court is in the process of banning their President and Prime Minister from politics for the next five years.

At the same time you will develop amazing skills, which will put you in great demand around the world, including back here (no matter what colour you are). The skills shortage is an international problem. In fact, according to the OECD, Britain (where the term “brain drain” originated) has lost more skilled professionals than any other country in the world over the past ten years. They are leaving for vibrant and sunny places like Sydney, Miami, Dubai and Cape Town, fleeing a massive increase in violent crime amongst British youth and ongoing immigration to Britain by people like you.

On a recent flight to Morocco I saw an advertisement for Louis Vuitton, which asked the question “Voyage-t-on pour découvrir le monde ou pour le changer?” (Do you travel to discover the world or to change it?) I think that the answer is both. By discovering the world, you see what is possible and you learn how things can be changed. This is why I am leading the charge to use the business community in the Cape to change our future. I’ve seen what can be achieved. Cape Town offers a unique blend of beauty, access to good universities, diverse cultures, great restaurants, a tremendous range of outdoor activities and the ability to access international businesses and three levels of government all in one place. That puts us in an enviable position to create what I refer to as the “Southern Tiger”, a rising power that stands above the rest. It just needs more people like you to travel abroad to experience what others have achieved in the face of similar challenges to ours, and then to come back here and apply the leadership, vision and self-confidence that we need to make it happen.

By the way, as you are leaving from one of our airports that are doubling as construction sites right now, remember that by the time you come home they will have been completed. There will also be new stadiums, roads, fast trains, power stations and harbours that you won’t have seen before. They are an important part of the R400 billion that we are spending on infrastructure to make sure that our economy keeps growing and that you will have more to come back to.

So take my advice and leave South Africa when you graduate. Go and see the world. But remember that, like the character in Paulo Coelho’s book “The Alchemist”, you might find that the treasure you are seeking is actually waiting to be discovered back home.

Related Posts

3 Responses to A good reason to go »»


Comments

  1. Comment by Jeremy Swanson | 2008/05/21 at 21:27:07

    You surely must be joking. I left South Africa 22 years ago for a brighter future and found it along with many in the 4th wave of emigration in the 1980’s. Today there is a 5th wave of emigration reaching out across the globe and just today 21st May 2008 I heard from three sets of friends in Cape Town and Johannesburg who are actively seeking foreign passports for their children and dusting off their own. In Toronto the largest city in Ontario province in Canada over 80,000 South Africans are known to be permanent residents and new citizens. In Vancouver that figure is close to 50,000 and growing.

    The largest single “ethnic group” in London outside of the London Indian population is the ex-pat South African population. Boerewors and Biltong shops and South African Pubs abound. They even have their own newspaper and the links to “The South African” are here: http://www.mailfox.co.uk/online.aspx?mid=4001980&cid=1004431996&eid=8938061

    I would guess that most of these working expats would be in South Africa if they wanted or could be there. Never before in history have there been so many South Africans in London or living abroad. In England it is far higher than when I lived there. I even ran into South African shop keepers in Oxford. Knowing the beauty and ‘call’ of South Africa I am certain most expats would rather be ein South Africa than overseas but the reality for them is a far cry from the story you would like to see. the truth is that South Africa is a mess in more ways than one and people now have no option but to leave. Crime is only one problem. Fear of the future especially under the incoming President Zuma will spur more to start packing. Many more will actually do so in the coming months and years.

    While your sentiments are sound the reality is that many of the South Africans I met in England regard themselves as being in “exile” others are working and living there temporally to earn money for their continuing education ‘back home’ and others, the majority of whom are over the age of 30, are permanent residents. There is definitely a “fifth wave” of emigration to the UK New Zealand and Australia going on. Providing stories of crime, power failures and other issues overseas to frighten South Africans into staying and not taking a chance overseas is spurious nonsense. Having lived here and in England and been back to South Africa 10 times in 17 years I can confirm that the living standards and risks comparisons are as chalk and cheese. South Africans thrive overseas and live extremely well. There is nothing close in any community to the dangers of living in South Africa. Even new York City is safer than Johannesburg. It never used to be like that.

    In 2004 while over in England and staying at a hotel in Gerrard’s Cross I realized that of the staff of 26 at that hotel, 18 were young (mostly white) South Africans under the age of 25. I was talking to the waitress at breakfast in Afrikaans. At the hotel bar I was quite surprised to be served by a barman in an English pub setting who came from Heilbron.
    The Economist magazine ran an article in 2005 on the South African brain drain, which stated “some 1.4 million South Africans are thought to be living in Britain alone”.

    Conventional wisdom says that close to 225,000 South Africans are living and working in London this time. The London South African Rugby team is a firm favourite. In my days there were London Irish, London Welsh, London Scottish, London Aussie and Kiwi but no London South African team. We played for various clubs like Wasps but were scattered. Now the whole game has changed with the ‘new blood’. “Braais” have become part a commonplace option of the London scene in backyards.

    I know its not a pleasant thought seeing so many leaving and leaving behind people such as yourself to ‘turn the lights off’ but the reality of life in SA is far different to the picture of hope you are trying so hard to portray. Even though I still miss my remaining family and friends, my beach and sunsets and my braais and mountain, I am sure glad I took off when I did.

    Jeremy Swanson
    Ottawa Canada

  2. Comment by Paula Marnitz | 2008/07/23 at 19:24:34

    Thank you Jeremy Swanson for putting it so succinctly. You are so right, I am so tired of hearing about how you can get mugged overseas and there are power cuts overseas……so boring. SA is going down the toilet, it’s bloody horrible here. I hate it. Living constantly in fear has taken its toll on my health and my personality. I am constantly irritable and my day revolves around keeping my kids and myself safe.
    We are leaving in 3 weeks and we are never coming back. I will not miss a thing about SA and although I will miss my friends, if they are dumb enough to stay here, then good luck to them but I am not coming back to visit.
    This place is finished, over, kaput and a million upbeat columns about how things are bad overseas will never convince smart people not to leave.

  3. Comment by South African optimist | 2008/12/08 at 11:09:26

    I am South African and I’ve lived abroad for more than 10 years. I returned last year in the hope of applying my extensive business knowledge operating at senior management level at some heavyweight MNCs and with a top-10 international business school MBA under my belt. I can say I am more than disappointed with the South Africa I’ve returned to - rampant uncontrolled crime, BEE fatcats, hardly any progress with respect to educating those that need it most, cronyism, lack of political accountability, the list continues..

    Paula and Jeremy - you’ve hit the nail on the head. There is crime everywhere in the world - that’s true. But the state of it in South Africa can certainly not be classified as normal. I am glad that you both relocated and best of luck to you both - there’s nothing worse than local whingers that do not put their money where their mouth is and do something about it if they’re not happy.

    I think you would all enjoy a post on the current South African situation based on a recent survey I came across on cartoon blog Wonkie.. check out: http://www.wonkie.com/2008/12/08/eternally-moaning-south-africans-cartoon/

    Naivete is a local genetic defect that will assume its Darwinian path soon enough for those foolish enough to ignore the real state of the country.


Leave a Reply »»

Close
E-mail It